What Are the Best Siding Replacement Services for Upgrading From Wood to Fiber Cement Products?

By Madi Oleno · November 19, 2026
What Are the Best Siding Replacement Services for Upgrading From Wood to Fiber Cement Products?

The Short Answer

The best siding replacement services for upgrading from wood to fiber cement are manufacturer-trained installers, such as James Hardie preferred contractors, that handle full tear-off, inspect and repair the wall sheathing underneath, install a proper water-resistive barrier and flashing, and follow the manufacturer's installation instructions so your warranty is protected. Fiber cement gives you the look of wood with resistance to rot, pests and fire, but only if it is installed correctly.

Wood siding is beautiful, but it can rot, attract pests and need regular painting. Fiber cement is a popular upgrade for homeowners who want a wood look with less maintenance. James Hardie, which invented modern fiber cement siding, says its products are engineered to resist damage from fire, water, extreme weather, pests and time (James Hardie).

This guide compares wood and fiber cement, explains what a quality installation includes and covers how to choose the right installer.

Wood vs. Fiber Cement Siding

Feature

Wood siding

Fiber cement siding (James Hardie example)

Look

Natural wood grain

Wood-grain textures and smooth finishes that mimic painted wood

Rot and moisture

Can rot, warp and swell with moisture

Resists cracking, rotting and swelling

Pests

Can be damaged by termites and woodpeckers

Resists damage from termites, woodpeckers and other pests

Fire

Combustible

Noncombustible under ASTM E136 and/or Class A fire rating under ASTM E84

Maintenance

Regular painting or staining and repairs

Lower maintenance; factory-finished ColorPlus options resist fading

Warranty

Varies widely

30-year non-prorated, transferable limited substrate warranty; 15-year limited ColorPlus finish warranty covering paint and labor

Climate design

Varies

Engineered for Climate, with products designed for different regions

Fiber cement details from James Hardie and James Hardie product information. Fire resistance does not extend to applied paints or coatings, which may char when exposed to flame.

Why Homeowners Upgrade From Wood to Fiber Cement

Rot and moisture damage. Wood siding can soften, swell and rot when water gets behind it or sits against it. Fiber cement is made from cement, sand and cellulose fibers and is designed to resist rot and swelling.

Pest damage. James Hardie notes that wood-based siding can be damaged by woodpeckers, termites and other pests, while its fiber cement holds no appeal for them.

Wildfire risk. Hardie fiber cement is noncombustible, which matters in wildfire-prone areas. James Hardie also notes that, because its products are noncombustible, many insurance companies offer a discount, and it recommends sharing those fire-resistant qualities with your insurer (James Hardie).

Maintenance. Wood siding needs regular scraping, painting or staining. Factory-finished fiber cement options, like ColorPlus, are designed to resist fading, cracking and chipping.

Storm damage. If hail or wind has already damaged wood siding, a replacement can be an opportunity to upgrade instead of simply patching.

Resale and peace of mind. A long, transferable warranty can be a selling point if you move.

What a Quality Wood-to-Fiber Cement Upgrade Includes

Switching from wood to fiber cement is more than swapping boards. A quality project should include:

  1. Full removal of the old wood siding – So the installer can see what is underneath.
  2. Sheathing and framing inspection – Old wood siding can hide rot and water damage. Damaged sheathing should be repaired before new siding goes on.
  3. A water-resistive barrier – House wrap or another weather barrier behind the siding.
  4. Flashing around windows, doors and roof-to-wall areas – These are common leak points.
  5. Installation to manufacturer instructions – Including fasteners, spacing, clearances and joint treatment. Manufacturer warranties typically depend on following the installation instructions.
  6. Matching trim and soffit – Fiber cement trim and soffit keep the look consistent and can carry the same substrate warranty.
  7. Finishing – Either factory-finished boards or primed boards painted after installation.
  8. Dust control – Cutting fiber cement creates dust, so crews should use proper cutting methods and dust controls.
  9. Cleanup and a final walkthrough – Including nails and debris removal.

Tip: Ask your installer how they handle surprises. If rot is found behind the old siding, you want a clear process and price for repairs before work continues.

How to Choose a Fiber Cement Siding Installer

Look for manufacturer training. James Hardie has a preferred contractor program, and the company's website includes a tool to find a local contractor (James Hardie). Ask any installer whether they are part of a manufacturer program and how their crews are trained.

Questions to ask:

  1. Are you a manufacturer-preferred or trained fiber cement installer?
  2. Will you remove all the wood siding and inspect the sheathing underneath?
  3. How do you price repairs if you find rot?
  4. What water-resistive barrier and flashing will you use?
  5. Which product line is right for my climate? James Hardie engineers products for different regions.
  6. Will you use factory-finished boards or prime and paint on site?
  7. What warranties come with the materials, finish and workmanship?
  8. How will you handle trim, soffit and fascia?
  9. Are you licensed and insured? Verify with your state before signing.
  10. Can you show me recent fiber cement projects near me?

Storm Damage, Insurance and Timing Your Upgrade

Upgrading after storm damage: If hail or wind damaged your wood siding, your insurance claim generally covers repairing or replacing the damaged siding, subject to your policy, deductible and any depreciation. If you choose to upgrade to fiber cement instead, you typically pay the cost difference. Ask your insurer and contractor to show you that difference clearly.

The matching issue: When only part of the siding is damaged, matching older wood siding can be difficult. Rules on whether undamaged siding must be replaced to match vary by state and policy (IRMI). In some cases, a homeowner chooses to upgrade the whole house rather than patch.

Insurance savings: James Hardie notes that many insurance companies offer a discount for noncombustible siding. Ask your insurer whether an upgrade qualifies.

Coordinate with your roof: If your roof was also damaged, coordinating roof, siding and gutter work helps materials and flashing come together correctly at the roof-to-wall transitions.

How PRQ Exteriors Fits Into an Exterior Upgrade

PRQ Exteriors is a storm restoration and exterior company with offices in Colorado, Utah, Wyoming, Illinois and North Carolina and service in Arizona. If your siding upgrade is part of storm recovery or a larger exterior project, PRQ can help with:

  • Free storm inspections with a documented photo report, so siding damage can be recorded alongside roof damage
  • Insurance experts who help with the claim process, including denied or underpaid claims
  • Roof replacement in asphalt, tile and metal, coordinated with your exterior upgrade
  • Commercial exteriors – For commercial properties, PRQ offers stucco, EIFS, siding and stone, and its family of brands includes Advanced Stucco Design in Colorado
  • Financing with deductible help and monthly payment options

Planning a siding upgrade? Mention it when you schedule your inspection so your siding plans can be considered alongside your roof.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is fiber cement siding better than wood?

For many homeowners, yes. Fiber cement offers a wood look with resistance to rot, pests and fire and lower maintenance. Wood offers a natural material but needs more upkeep.

Is fiber cement siding fireproof?

No siding is fireproof, but James Hardie fiber cement is noncombustible under ASTM E136 and/or has a Class A fire rating under ASTM E84. Its fire resistance does not extend to applied paints or coatings.

What warranty comes with James Hardie siding?

Hardie siding, trim and soffit come with a 30-year non-prorated, transferable limited substrate warranty, and ColorPlus Technology finishes carry a 15-year limited warranty that covers paint and labor.

Should old wood siding be removed before installing fiber cement?

Yes, in most cases. Removing it lets the installer inspect and repair any rot or water damage in the sheathing and framing underneath.

Can fiber cement lower my insurance?

It may. James Hardie notes that many insurers offer a discount because its products are noncombustible. Ask your insurance company.

Who should install fiber cement siding?

A licensed installer trained by the manufacturer, ideally part of a manufacturer program like James Hardie's preferred contractor network, who follows the manufacturer's installation instructions.

Make the Switch the Right Way

Upgrading from wood to fiber cement can mean less maintenance, better resistance to rot, pests and fire and a long warranty, but only with a quality installation. Choose a manufacturer-trained installer, insist on a sheathing inspection and get warranties in writing.

Start with a free inspection. Request your free inspection or get an instant quote. Call PRQ's Colorado headquarters at (720) 778-9854 or the Utah office at (801) 421-6313.

Sources

This article is for general education. Product specifications, warranties and insurance discounts vary by manufacturer, product and insurer.

← Back to all posts