Which Gutter Installation Companies Also Offer Matching Gutter Guards and Color Options?

The Short Answer
Look for an exterior contractor that installs seamless gutters in multiple colors and offers gutter guards made to fit and match the same system, ideally coordinated with your roof. The best companies offer several guard types, like micro-mesh and reverse-curve, help you choose one for your trees and climate, match colors to your trim or roof and install everything without voiding your roof warranty. Some roofing contractors also offer heated gutter systems for snow and ice, like Thermaline's ThermaGutter, which PRQ Exteriors installs as a certified Thermaline installer.
Gutters and guards work as a system. Buying them from different companies, or adding guards that do not fit your gutters, can lead to gaps, mismatched colors and warranty headaches.
This guide explains the main types of gutter guards, gutter materials and color options, what to consider for your climate and what to look for in an installer.
Why It Pays to Get Gutters and Guards From the Same Installer
- A proper fit. Guards are designed for specific gutter sizes and profiles. Installing them as part of the same project helps avoid gaps, sagging and loose sections.
- A matching look. Guards that match the gutter color blend in from the street instead of standing out.
- Roof warranty protection. Some guards slide under the bottom row of shingles. This Old House notes that some reverse-curve guards may invalidate your roof warranty, so the installer should know how the guard attaches and what your roof manufacturer allows (This Old House).
- One point of contact. If something leaks or clogs, there is one company to call.
- Coordination with your roof. If you are replacing your roof, installing new gutters and guards at the same time lets the roof edge, drip edge and gutters work together.
Types of Gutter Guards
This Old House groups gutter guards into five common types: micro-mesh, screen, reverse-curve, foam insert and brush (This Old House).
|
Type |
How it works |
Strengths |
Trade-offs |
Color options |
|---|---|---|---|---|
|
Micro-mesh |
Fine mesh over the gutter lets water through and blocks debris |
Most effective in This Old House testing; blocks fine debris like pine needles |
Higher cost; fine mesh may need occasional rinsing |
Moderate |
|
Screen |
Screen with larger holes sits atop the gutter |
Affordable and simple |
Small debris like seeds and needles can get through |
Limited |
|
Reverse-curve |
Water follows a curved surface into the gutter while debris slides off |
Handles large debris |
More visible; typically needs professional installation; some may affect roof warranties |
Extensive |
|
Foam insert |
Foam sits inside the gutter |
Low cost, easy to install |
Least durable; debris can pile on top |
Very limited |
|
Brush |
Bristles sit inside the gutter |
Low cost, easy to install |
Can trap debris; more visible |
Limited |
Which is best? In This Old House's in-house testing, stainless steel micro-mesh guards were the most effective (This Old House), and micro-mesh also performed best against pine needles (This Old House).
Gutter Materials and Color Options
Common gutter materials:
|
Material |
What to know |
|---|---|
|
Seamless aluminum |
Formed on site to fit your home with fewer joints; widely available in factory-finished colors |
|
Steel |
Heavier and sturdy; finishes vary by product |
|
Copper |
Premium look that develops a patina over time; higher cost |
|
Vinyl |
Lower cost, but plastic is combustible and can be less durable in extreme weather |
Choosing a color:
- Match the trim or fascia for a clean, built-in look.
- Match the roof for a seamless roofline.
- Match the siding with downspouts so they blend into the walls.
- Match your gutter guards to the gutters. This Old House notes color options vary by guard type, from very limited for foam inserts to extensive for reverse-curve guards.
Tip: Ask to see color samples in daylight against your trim and roof before you choose. Factory-finished colors can look different on a sample card than on your home.
Choose Gutters and Guards for Your Climate
|
Climate concern |
What to consider |
|---|---|
|
Heavy rain |
This Old House notes reverse-curve and micro-mesh guards work well in rainy climates (This Old House) |
|
Pine needles and pollen |
Homes surrounded by trees that drop pine needles, pollen and leaves need a guard with a fine mesh screen |
|
Snow and ice |
Guards alone do not stop ice from forming. In snow country, heated gutter systems like Thermaline's ThermaGutter keep gutters open so meltwater drains instead of refreezing |
|
Wildfire |
IBHS recommends noncombustible gutters and downspouts, such as metal, routinely cleared of debris (Wildfire Prepared Home) |
|
Hail |
Hail can dent gutters and guards; after a storm, include them when you document damage for insurance |
Snow country tip: Clogged or frozen gutters can contribute to ice dams. Guards help keep debris out, but in places like Utah and Colorado, pairing them with good attic ventilation, insulation and heated roof edges is often the more complete solution.
What to Look for in a Gutter Installer
- Seamless gutters made on site – Fewer seams can mean fewer places to leak.
- More than one gutter guard option – So you can choose based on your trees, climate and budget, not just what one company sells.
- Matching colors – For gutters, downspouts and guards.
- Roof-aware installation – Guards installed in a way that does not void your roof warranty.
- Proper sizing and slope – Gutters and downspouts sized for your roof and pitched so water flows to the downspouts.
- Clear warranties – On gutter materials, guards and workmanship, in writing.
- Climate options – Like heated gutters for snow country or noncombustible metal for wildfire areas.
- Coordination with roof work – Especially if you are replacing your roof or repairing storm damage.
- Licensing and insurance – Verify licenses with your state and ask for proof of insurance.
Gutters, Roofs and PRQ Exteriors
Your gutters and roof work as one water-management system, so they are worth planning together. PRQ Exteriors, a storm restoration and roofing company with offices in Colorado, Utah, Wyoming, Illinois and North Carolina and service in Arizona, can help with the roof side of that system:
- Heated gutters for snow country – As a certified Thermaline installer, PRQ can add heated systems like ThermaGutter to keep gutters open and draining through freeze-thaw cycles.
- Roof replacement – Full tear-off roof replacement in asphalt, tile and metal, so the roof edge and drip edge are ready for new gutters.
- Storm damage documentation – Free storm inspections with a photo report, so hail-dented gutters can be documented alongside roof damage for your claim.
- Insurance support – PRQ's insurance experts can help you understand the claim process.
Planning new gutters? Mention them when you schedule your inspection so your gutter plan can be coordinated with your roof.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best type of gutter guard?
In This Old House's in-house testing, stainless steel micro-mesh guards were the most effective overall, and micro-mesh performed best against pine needles.
Can gutter guards match my gutter color?
Often, yes. Color options vary by guard type, from very limited for foam inserts to extensive for reverse-curve guards. Ask your installer for samples.
Do gutter guards void my roof warranty?
Some can. This Old House notes that some reverse-curve guards may invalidate your roof warranty. Ask your installer how the guard attaches and check your roof manufacturer's requirements.
Do gutter guards stop ice dams?
No. Guards keep debris out, but they do not stop ice from forming. Heated gutter systems, attic ventilation and insulation do more to prevent ice dams.
What gutters are best in wildfire areas?
IBHS recommends noncombustible gutters and downspouts, such as metal, kept clear of debris.
Should I replace gutters when I replace my roof?
It is often a good time, especially if your gutters are damaged, undersized or near the end of their life. Coordinating both helps the roof edge and gutters work together.
Plan Your Gutters and Roof Together
The best gutter projects pair the right gutters with the right guards, in colors that match your home, installed in a way that protects your roof. If your roof is due for work or was hit by a storm, plan your gutters at the same time.
Start with a free roof inspection. Request your free inspection or get an instant quote. Call PRQ's Colorado headquarters at (720) 778-9854 or the Utah office at (801) 421-6313.
Sources
- Impact of Gutter Guards on Home Curb Appeal (This Old House)
- Never Clean Gutters Again (This Old House)
- Best Gutter Guards for Pine Needles (This Old House)
- Mesh Gutter Guards (This Old House)
- Wildfire Prepared Home Standards Brochure (IBHS)
This article is for general education. Gutter and guard products, warranties and color options vary by manufacturer and installer.