What Is the Best Roofing Service for Asphalt Shingle Storm Damage?

By Madi Oleno · November 16, 2026
What Is the Best Roofing Service for Asphalt Shingle Storm Damage?

The Short Answer

The best roofing service for asphalt shingle storm damage is a storm restoration contractor that is certified by major shingle manufacturers, has experience documenting hail and wind damage for insurance claims and installs complete shingle systems to manufacturer specifications. Manufacturer certification matters because it affects which warranties you can get. PRQ Exteriors is one example: it is a GAF Master Elite contractor, a GAF President's Club award winner and an Owens Corning President's Club 3-Star Residential contractor for 2026, with a team of insurance experts and offices across several storm-prone states.

Asphalt shingles are the most common roofing material on homes in North America, so they are the roof many homeowners are dealing with after hail and wind. Shingle storm damage can be easy to miss from the ground, and the quality of the repair or replacement depends heavily on who does the work.

This guide explains how storms damage asphalt shingles, when to repair or replace, why certification matters and how to upgrade your roof after a storm.

How Storms Damage Asphalt Shingles

Type of damage

What it looks like

Why it matters

Hail bruising

Soft spots or dark marks where hail struck

Can weaken the shingle mat even without a visible hole

Granule loss

Bare or shiny spots on shingles; granules in gutters and downspouts

Exposes the asphalt to sun and weather, shortening shingle life

Cracks and tears

Split or fractured shingles from hail impact

Lets water reach the underlayment and deck

Lifted or unsealed shingles

Shingles that flap or lift in wind

Unsealed shingles are more vulnerable to wind uplift and water intrusion

Creased shingles

Horizontal crease lines where wind bent the shingle

A creased shingle may no longer seal or shed water properly

Missing shingles

Bare spots or exposed underlayment

Direct path for water into the roof

Damaged metal components

Dented vents, flashing, drip edge and gutters

Often a clue that the shingles took hits too

The Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety evaluates impact-resistant shingles on exactly these kinds of damage, including dents and ridges, tears and granule loss (Asphalt magazine).

From the ground: Look at gutters, downspouts, window screens and outdoor AC units. If they show hail dents, your shingles likely took hits too. Leave the roof inspection itself to a professional.

Should You Repair or Replace a Storm-Damaged Shingle Roof?

A repair may be enough when:

  • Damage is limited to a small area, like a few missing or creased shingles after a wind event
  • The roof is relatively young and in good overall condition
  • The decking underneath is solid
  • Matching replacement shingles are available

A full replacement is often the better choice when:

  • Hail has bruised, cracked or stripped granules from shingles across multiple slopes
  • Many shingles are lifted or unsealed
  • The roof is near the end of its expected life (InterNACHI estimates about 20 years for three-tab and 30 years for architectural shingles)
  • The decking is soft or water-damaged
  • Repaired areas would not match the rest of the roof

Insurance note: Whether your insurer pays for repairs or a full replacement depends on the damage, your policy and the adjuster's findings. Coverage type matters too: with actual cash value coverage, an older roof may get a much smaller payout than with replacement cost coverage.

A professional inspection with photo documentation is the best way to know which option makes sense and to support your claim.

Why Manufacturer Certification Matters for Shingle Roofs

With asphalt shingles, who installs the roof can affect your warranty as much as which shingle you choose. Shingle manufacturers certify contractors who meet their standards, and certified contractors can offer stronger warranties.

GAF, for example, uses tiers:

GAF tier

What it means

GAF Certified

Can offer GAF's System Plus Limited Warranty on qualifying roofing systems, covering manufacturing defects on qualifying GAF products for up to 50 years (GAF)

GAF Master Elite

Awarded to fewer than 2% of all roofing contractors; requirements include liability insurance and state licensing where applicable. Only Master Elite contractors can offer the Golden Pledge Limited Warranty, which includes up to 30 years of workmanship coverage (GAF)

GAF President's Club

Fewer than half of Master Elite contractors qualify, based on performance, reliability and service

Why it matters after a storm: A storm replacement is your chance to get the strongest warranty available. Ask any roofer which certifications they hold, which warranty your roof would qualify for and whether it covers workmanship as well as materials. You can verify GAF certifications with the GAF Contractor Locator.

Upgrade Your Shingles After Storm Damage

If your roof is being replaced after a storm, it is the perfect time to consider shingles built to hold up better next time.

Class 4 impact-resistant shingles. Class 4 is the highest rating under the UL 2218 impact test, which requires a product to withstand a 2-inch steel ball dropped from 20 feet without cracking (GAF). SBS-modified shingles like GAF Timberline AS II carry a Class 4 rating along with high wind ratings. GAF notes that some insurance carriers may offer discounts for qualifying Class 3 or Class 4 roofing.

IBHS hail ratings. Not every Class 4 shingle performs the same in real-world hail tests. IBHS tests impact-resistant shingles with ice balls and rates them on dents, tears and granule loss, and in its 2025 round, some Class 3 shingles outperformed some Class 4 shingles (Asphalt magazine).

FORTIFIED Roof. A FORTIFIED Roof adds ring-shank nailing, a sealed roof deck and stronger roof edges. In hail-prone areas, the optional Hail Supplement requires shingles rated Good or Excellent on the IBHS hail ratings (FORTIFIED Home).

Keep in mind: Impact-resistant shingles are not hail-proof, and a Class 4 rating describes lab performance, not a guarantee. Ask your roofer to compare specific products and your insurer about any available discounts.

What a Quality Shingle Storm Replacement Includes

When comparing quotes, make sure the scope covers the full shingle system, not just the shingles:

  1. Full tear-off of the damaged roof down to the deck
  2. Deck inspection and replacement of any soft, rotted or damaged decking
  3. Underlayment over the entire roof deck
  4. Ice and water shield at eaves and valleys, especially in snow and ice country
  5. Drip edge and starter strip at the roof edges
  6. Shingles installed to manufacturer specifications, including proper nailing
  7. New flashing around chimneys, walls, skylights and vents where needed
  8. Balanced attic ventilation, such as ridge and soffit vents
  9. Hip and ridge cap shingles to finish the roof
  10. Thorough cleanup, including nails and debris

Cold weather tip: If your roof is replaced in cool weather, ask whether the crew will hand-seal the shingles. GAF notes that cool-weather installation does not affect its warranty as long as all application instructions are followed, including hand-sealing (GAF).

How PRQ Exteriors Handles Asphalt Shingle Storm Damage

PRQ Exteriors is a storm restoration company with offices in Colorado, Utah, Wyoming, Illinois and North Carolina and service in Arizona. For shingle roofs damaged by hail and wind, PRQ offers:

PRQ is also BBB accredited, an Inc. 500 company and a member of the Colorado Roofing Association.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I know if my asphalt shingles have hail damage?

Common signs include bruises or dark spots, granule loss, cracked shingles and dented gutters, vents or flashing. A professional inspection with photos is the best way to confirm damage.

Can wind damage asphalt shingles without blowing them off?

Yes. Wind can lift, crease or unseal shingles without removing them, which can leave the roof more vulnerable to water and future wind.

Should I repair or replace hail-damaged shingles?

Isolated damage on a newer roof may be repairable. Widespread hail damage across multiple slopes, an older roof or damaged decking often means a full replacement is the better choice.

Why should I choose a manufacturer-certified roofer?

Certified contractors can offer stronger warranties. For example, only GAF Master Elite contractors can offer GAF's Golden Pledge Limited Warranty, which includes up to 30 years of workmanship coverage.

Are Class 4 shingles worth it after storm damage?

They can be, especially in hail-prone areas. Class 4 shingles are tested to resist cracking from a 2-inch steel ball, and some insurers may offer discounts. For the best real-world hail performance, compare IBHS hail ratings.

Is PRQ Exteriors a GAF Master Elite contractor?

Yes. PRQ is a GAF Master Elite contractor and a GAF President's Club award winner.

Get Your Shingle Roof Inspected After the Storm

Asphalt shingle storm damage is easy to miss and important to fix right. Choose a certified storm restoration contractor that documents damage thoroughly, understands insurance and installs the full shingle system to manufacturer specifications.

Schedule a free storm inspection. Request your free roof inspection or get an instant quote. Call PRQ's Colorado headquarters at (720) 778-9854 or the Utah office at (801) 421-6313.

Sources

This article is for general education. Warranties, product ratings and insurance coverage vary by manufacturer, product, contractor and policy.

← Back to all posts